The Most Complete Pump Failure Analysis!!!

1.Analysis of the cause of water pump failure

(1)There's air in the intake pipes and pumps
The self-priming pump does not fill enough water before starting, sometimes it seems that the water has been poured from the vent hole, but the air is completely discharged without rotating the pump shaft, resulting in a little air remaining in the inlet pipe or the pump body.

(2) The horizontal section of the water inlet pipe in contact with the pump should have a downward slope of more than 0.5% in the direction of the reverse water flow, and the end connected to the inlet of the pump should be the highest, not completely level. If it is tilted upward, the inlet pipe will retain air, reducing the vacuum in the pipe and pump, and affecting the water absorption.

(3) The packing of the single-stage centrifugal pump has been worn or the packing is too loose due to long-term use, resulting in a large amount of water from the gap between the packing and the pump shaft sleeve, and the result is that the external air enters the inside of the pump from these gaps, affecting the water lifting.

(4) The water inlet pipe due to long-term potential underwater, pipe wall corrosion holes, the water surface continues to fall after the pump work, when these holes emerge from the water surface, the air enters the water inlet pipe from the holes.

(5) Cracks appear at the bend of the inlet pipe, and small gaps appear at the connection between the inlet pipe and the pump, which may cause air to enter the inlet pipe.

 

2.Low pump speed

(1) Human factors. Some users due to the damage of the original motor, they will be randomly equipped with another motor, resulting in small flow, low head and even no water consequences.

(2) The mechanical failure of the pump itself. The impeller and pump shaft fastening nut loose or pump shaft deformation and bending, resulting in more movement of the impeller, direct friction with the pump body, or bearing damage, may reduce the speed of the pump.

(3) Engine maintenance is not good. The motor loses magnetism because the winding is burned, and the change of winding turns, wire diameter, wiring method in maintenance, or the failure is not completely eliminated in maintenance will also change the speed of the pump.

 

3.The suction of the pump is too large

Some water sources are deeper, some water sources are relatively flat in the outer terrain, and the allowable suction range of the pump is ignored, resulting in less or no water absorption. It is necessary to know that the vacuum degree that can be established at the suction port of the self-priming centrifugal pump is limited, and the suction range of the absolute vacuum is about 10 meters high, and the pump can not establish an absolute vacuum. And the vacuum is too large, easy to make the water in the pump gasification, unfavorable to the work of the pump. Therefore, each centrifugal pump has its maximum allowable suction range, generally between 3-8.5 meters. The installation of the pump must not be simple and convenient.

 

4.The resistance loss in the inlet and outlet pipes of water flow is too large

Some users have measured that although the vertical distance of the reservoir or water tower to the water surface is slightly less than the centrifugal pump head, it is still a small amount of water or no water. The reason is often too long pipe, pipe bends, water flow in the pipe resistance loss is too large. The reason is often too long pipe, pipe bends, water flow in the pipe resistance loss is too large. Under normal circumstances, the resistance of 90 degree bending pipe is greater than that of 120 degree bending pipe, and the head loss of each 90 degree bending pipe is about 0.5-1 meters, and the resistance of each 20 meters pipe can make the head loss of about 1 meter. In addition, some users also arbitrarily pump into and out of the pipe diameter, which also has a certain impact on the head.

 

5.Influence of other factors

(1) The bottom valve cannot be opened. Usually because the pump has been sitting for too long, the bottom valve gasket is glued on, and the bottom valve without a gasket may rust.

(2) the bottom valve filter screen is blocked; Or bottom valve potential water sludge layer caused by the screen blockage.

(3) The impeller is seriously worn. The impeller blade is worn after long-term use, which affects the performance of the pump.

(4) The failure or blockage of the gate valve check valve will cause the flow rate to decrease or even no water to be pumped.

(5) Leakage of the outlet pipeline will also affect the amount of water extracted.

 

 

Simple equipment fault diagnosis methods are commonly used

① Auscultation
When the equipment is in normal operation, the accompanying sound always has a certain rhythm and rhythm. As long as you are familiar with and master these normal rhythms and rhythms, through the human hearing function, you can compare whether the equipment has heavy, miscellaneous, strange, chaotic abnormal noise, and judge the hidden dangers such as loosening, impact, and imbalance inside the equipment. Knock the parts with a hand hammer and listen to whether there is a cracking noise to determine whether there is a crack. An electronic stethoscope is a vibration acceleration sensor. It converts the vibration of the equipment into an electrical signal and amplifies it, and workers use headphones to monitor the vibration sound of the operating equipment to achieve qualitative measurement of the sound. By measuring the same point, different periods, the same speed, the same working conditions of the signal, and compare, to determine whether there is a fault in the equipment. When the earphone has a crisp and sharp noise, it indicates that the vibration frequency is high, and the local defects or small cracks are generally occurring in parts with relatively small size and relatively high strength. When the muffled noise from the earphone comes out, it indicates that the vibration frequency is low, and generally large cracks or defects occur in parts with relatively large size and relatively low strength. When the noise coming out of the headset is stronger than usual, it indicates that the fault is developing, and the louder the noise, the more serious the fault. When the noise coming out of the headset is chaotic and irregular intermittently, it indicates that a part or component is loose.

 

② Touch method
The touch of the human hand can monitor the temperature, vibration and clearance changes of the equipment.
The nerve fibers in the human hand are more sensitive to temperature and can more accurately distinguish the temperature within 80 ° C. When the temperature of the machine is about 0 ° C, it feels cold, and if it is touched for a long time, it will produce a piercing pain. When it is about 10 ° C, it feels cool, but it can generally be tolerated. At about 20℃, the feel is slightly cool, and with the extension of contact time, the feel is gradually warm. When it is about 30℃, it feels warm and comfortable. When it is about 40℃, it feels hot and slightly hot. When it is about 50 ° C, it feels hot, and if it is pressed with the palm for a long time, it will feel sweaty. When it is about 60 ° C, it feels very hot, but it can generally tolerate 10s for a long time. When it is about 70 ° C, the feel is burning and painful, which can only be tolerated for a long time, and the touch of the hand will quickly turn red. When touching, you should try to touch it and then touch it carefully to estimate the temperature rise of the machine. Shake the parts with your hand to feel the gap size of 0.1mm-0.3mm. By touching the machine with the hand, you can feel the change of the strength of the vibration and whether there is an impact, as well as the crawling situation of the slide. Measuring the surface temperature of rolling bearing, plain bearing, headstock, motor and other parts with thermometer equipped with surface thermocouple probe has the characteristics of rapid determination of thermal anomaly location, accurate data and convenient touch measurement process.

 

③Method of observation
Human vision can observe whether the parts on the equipment are loose, cracked and other damage; Can check whether the lubrication is normal, there is dry friction and running, bubbling, dripping, leakage phenomenon; You can check the amount, size and characteristics of metal wear particles in the tank sediment to judge the wear of related parts; Can monitor whether the equipment movement is normal, there is no abnormal phenomenon; You can watch a variety of instruments installed on the equipment to reflect the working status of the equipment, understand the change of the data, you can measure the quality of the product and judge the working status of the equipment by measuring tools and directly observing the surface condition. By comprehensive analysis of all kinds of information observed, we can judge whether there is a fault in the equipment, the fault location, the fault degree and the cause of the fault. Through the instrument, the wear particles collected from the lubricating oil of the equipment are observed. The simple way to realize the wear condition monitoring is the magnetic plug method. Its principle is to insert a magnetic plug head into the lubricating oil, collect the iron abrasive particles produced by wear, and judge the degree of wear on the surface of the mechanical parts by observing the size, quantity and shape characteristics of the abrasive particles with the help of a reading microscope or direct human eyes. Magnetic plug method can be used to observe the large size of abrasive particles in the later wear period of mechanical parts. During observation, if small abrasive particles are found and the number is small, it indicates that the equipment is operating normally. If large abrasive particles are found, attention should be paid to the operation of the equipment. If large particles are found repeatedly, it is a precursor of an imminent failure, and it should be stopped immediately for inspection, to find the fault, and to eliminate it. As I said in detail, these diagnostic methods require a long period of experience to be accurate.

 

7.Pump trip troubleshooting

(1)Fault phenomenon
Since the 125mw unit of the power plant was put into operation, the water pump occasionally had the problem of tripping at a close, and no signal relay had dropped. After the fault of the switching mechanism is eliminated, the cables, secondary circuit wiring and each relay and its setting are normal according to the conventional method, and the restart is often successful. It is suspected that the dcs system is caused by soft failure, but it is still possible to operate on the control disk.

(2)Test to find the cause
In order to find out the cause of this phenomenon, observe the change of each meter during the switch closing process to confirm what causes it to trip. In the test, the voltmeter monitors the microcomputer tripping circuit, the milliammeter monitors the 1cj and 2cj operation of the differential relay, and the ammeter monitors the thermal protection circuit. After the meter is connected, the feed pump is started, after a period of test, there is finally a pump trip once started, and it is observed that the pointer of the milliammeter deflates a little, other monitoring meters do not react, and the newly replaced xjl-0025/31 integrated block signal relay 1xj also moves off, indicating that the trip is caused by the differential protection action.

(3)Root cause analysis
Differential protection action, first suspect that there is a fault inside the protected equipment. Through the routine inspection, the pump motor and its cable are normal, the differential relay is normal, and the polarity of the current transformer is correctly connected. After the cause of equipment failure and wiring error is eliminated, the differential protection is activated during the motor start-up process, indicating that the differential current of the differential circuit exceeds the differential relay setting value in this process. Under normal circumstances, there are two main reasons for the differential circuit differential current: First, the ratio error of the current transformer on both sides of the motor is different, and there is a small differential current, which is less than 5% of the rated current id of the motor. Second, the difference of secondary load on both sides of the head and tail current transformer will also cause the difference in its ratio, so there is a difference current. The current transformer load difference in the differential protection circuit of the pump motor is only the difference in the length of the secondary cable, about 50 m, and at the rated current, the power consumption of the differential relay is not more than 3 va, and the secondary load is not heavy. It is found that the end and end current transformers used for differential protection of feed pump motor are all lmzbj-10, class b 15 times rated current, variable ratio 600/5, capacity 40 va, which can fully meet the requirements of secondary load.

The above analysis is based on normal operation conditions, and the situation is different when the motor is started. When the motor starts, the current is very large, and the current transformers at both sides of the head and tail may be saturated. At this time, due to the inconsistent magnetization characteristics of each current transformer, the secondary difference current may be very large. According to the setting description of LC-12 differential relay of Acheng Relay Factory, the operation current setting value of relay izd=△i1×kk×in/n=0.06×3×356/120=0.534a: △i1 - the maximum error of the first and tail current transformer during normal operation, 0.04 ~ 0.06; kk - reliability factor, 2 ~ 3; in - rated current of motor; n - Current transformer ratio. Should be set at 1.0a position. In the case of the B-level transformer, when the differential relay operating current is set at 1.5a and the braking coefficient is 0.4, the differential protection will still occasionally act when the motor is started, because the B-level current transformer has a low saturation point of magnetization characteristics and low anti-saturation ability, which cannot meet the requirements of the differential relay. The current transformer of the differential protection circuit is usually required to use d level, and the saturation point of the D-level transformer is higher and less easily saturated, which can reduce the differential current flowing through the differential circuit when the motor is started. After replacing the current transformer with the d level, and setting the operating current of the differential relay at 1.0a and the braking coefficient at 0.4, the failure of tripping once the switch is closed did not occur again.

 

8.Failure treatment and discussion of pump mechanical seal

The mechanical seal is also called the end seal, which relies on the pressure of the spring and the sealing medium to produce the appropriate compression force on the contact surface of the rotating dynamic ring and the static ring, so that the two end faces are closely fitted. An extremely thin oil film is maintained between the end faces, and the resistance of the medium is great to prevent liquid leakage, so as to achieve the purpose of sealing, and at the same time, it has a lubricating effect on the moving ring and the static ring. Well adjusted can be completely leak-free.

(1)Characteristics of the pump mechanical seal
The main advantage of the pump mechanical seal is that the seal is reliable, and the leakage is very little in a long service cycle; Long life, generally can be used for about 5 years; Long maintenance cycle. However, the mechanical seal structure is complex, the manufacturing and installation accuracy is high, the cost is high, and the technical requirements of the maintenance personnel are high, because the mechanical seal used in the oil pipeline is built-in, the repair of the mechanical seal often has to disintegrate the oil pump, and the workload is large. Therefore, it is very important to ensure that the mechanical seal works reliably and extend the service life of the mechanical seal.

(2)Pump mechanical seal easy to occur problems
In the process of use, the main problems that mechanical seals are prone to occur are excessive leakage and high temperature. Touch the mechanical seal gland with your hand. If you cannot stay on it, the temperature is too high. The leakage amount should not exceed 60 drops/min on each side, if it flows in a linear manner, it indicates that the leakage is too large, and it can be determined whether to observe the operation; If the oil is sprayed outwards, it should be stopped immediately for inspection.

(3)Control measures taken
①Ensure the quality of parts
Mechanical seals must be tested for sealing performance before leaving the factory, and there is a certificate. Mechanical seal after long-term operation, so that the dynamic ring and static ring wear, spring and shaft corrosion wear, sealing rubber ring wear, aging, deformation, etc., can cause seal leakage, must be repaired or replaced with new parts. The sealing surface of the moving ring and the static ring shall not have cracks, off corners, scratches, pitting, flash and partial wear, and the scratches and pitting shall not run through the entire sealing end face. If the repaired dynamic ring is used, the sum of the height of the boss of the dynamic ring is not less than 3mm, and the height of a single boss is not less than lmm, so as not to affect heat dissipation. After the dynamic ring is installed, it should ensure that it can move flexibly on the shaft, and it should be able to spring back freely after pressing the dynamic ring to the spring, and keep the vertical and parallel of the dynamic ring. The specifications of the dynamic and dynamic ring sealing rubber ring meet the requirements of the drawings, and the surface shall not be damaged, uneven thickness and uneven hardness, and the sealing rubber ring shall be replaced during overhaul. The outer surface of the spring is clean and no rust, and the length contour detection and pressure test should be carried out before use. The pressure difference of each group of springs in the specified compression length should meet the requirements, and the pressure error of each group of springs in the specified compression length should meet the requirements. The free length tolerance does not exceed 0.5mm, and the compression amount cannot be too large or too small, requiring an error of ±2mm. The sealing sleeve and the pump shaft can not be made of the same material, and the parallelism tolerance of both sides of the end face and the non-vertical tolerance with the axis should not exceed ± 0.20mm.

②Adequate cooling lubrication is guaranteed
Adjust the opening of the cooling pipe regulating valve, ensure that the mechanical seal cooling pipe is smooth, and open the emptying valve when the tank pump to drain the gas in the sealing chamber.

③Ensure installation accuracy
When disassembling the mechanical seal of the pump, the dynamic and static ring should be cleaned, and a small amount of clean lubricating oil should be applied on the friction surface, taking into account the high pressure end and the low pressure end, and it is strictly prohibited to bump. When installing the static ring gland, the force should be uniform to prevent pressure deviation, check with a feeler, and the deviation of the left and right positions is not greater than 0.05mm; Check the fit gap between the gland and the outside diameter of the shaft, and it should be uniform all around, and the allowable deviation of each point is not more than 0.1ram. The radial runout of the pump shaft installed in the mechanical seal part of the pump does not exceed 0.05mm. Before the pump cover and sealing end cover, it is necessary to carefully review the installation positioning size of the mechanical seal, if the positioning size does not meet the requirements, the steel pad can be adjusted between the shaft bushing, but the precision of the steel pad is high, and the thickness difference is not more than 0.01mm. Measuring the radial runout of the mechanical seal sleeve and the end runout of the sealing surface meet the requirements.
For the mechanical seal that has been run, where the gland is loose so that the sealing surface moves, the dynamic and static ring parts must be replaced, and should never be re-tightened to continue to use. Because after loosening in this way, the original motion trajectory of the friction pair will change, and the sealing performance of the contact surface will be easily damaged.

④Adjust the end specific pressure
The specific pressure of the end face is an important parameter related to the performance and service life of the seal, which is related to the structure type of the seal, the size of the spring and the medium pressure. The end specific pressure is too large will aggravate the friction pair; If the specific pressure is too small, it is easy to leak, often given by the manufacturer a suitable range, the end specific pressure is generally 3 ~ 6kg/cm2. To adjust the specific pressure is to adjust the compression size of the spring. The free length of the spring is expressed by A, the load borne by the spring stiffness when the unit compression is generated is k, and the specified specific pressure is expressed by P, which are all parameters given by the manufacturer. The compressed size is represented by B, then P/A-13=k, resulting in 13=A-e/k, which is the size after the spring is installed and compressed. If the size of the spring is too large after installation, the thickness of the adjustment pad can be increased between the spring seat and the spring, the size is too small, the adjustment thickness is reduced, and the thickness of the adjustment pad is measured with a micrometer.

 

9.Pump fault diagnosis and elimination measures

In the maintenance process, the diagnosis of the pump fault is a key link, the following are several common faults and elimination measures, for everyone to carry out targeted diagnosis of the pump fault.

{1} no liquid supply, insufficient supply of liquid or insufficient pressure
(1) The pump is not filled with water or is not properly vented
Elimination measures: Check that the pump housing and inlet line are fully filled with liquid.
2) The pump speed is too low
Elimination measures: check whether the motor wiring is correct, whether the voltage is normal or whether the steam pressure of the turbine is normal.
3) The water head of the pump system is too high
Elimination measures: Check the water head of the system (especially the friction loss).
4) The suction of the pump is too high
Elimination measures: Check the existing net pressure head (the inlet line is too small or too long will cause a great loss of friction).
5) The pump impeller or pipeline is blocked
Elimination measures: check for obstacles.
6) The pump rotates in the wrong direction
Elimination measures: check the rotation direction.
7) The pump produces air or the inlet line is leaking
Elimination: Check the inlet line for air pockets and/or air leaks.
8) The packing or seal in the pump packing box is worn, causing air to leak into the pump housing
Elimination measures: check the packing or seal and replace it as needed to check whether the lubrication is normal.
9) Insufficient suction head when the pump pumps hot or volatile liquids
Elimination measures: increase the suction head, consult the manufacturer.
10)pump Bottom valve is too small
Elimination measures: Install the correct size of the bottom valve.

11) The submersion depth of the bottom valve or inlet pipe of the pump is not enough
Elimination measures: Consult the manufacturer for the correct immersion depth. Use baffles to eliminate eddy currents.
12) The clearance of the pump impeller is too large
Elimination measures: Check whether the gap is correct.
13) Water pump impeller is damaged
Elimination measures: Check the impeller and replace it as required.
14) The impeller diameter of the pump is too small
Elimination measures: Consult the manufacturer for the correct impeller diameter.
15) The position of the water pump pressure gauge is incorrect
Elimination measures: Check whether the position is correct, check the outlet nozzle or pipe.

 

{2}the pump will stop after running for a while
1) The suction is too high
Elimination measures: Check the existing net pressure head (the inlet line is too small or too long will cause a great loss of friction).
2) The impeller or pipeline is blocked
Elimination measures: check for obstacles.
3) Air is generated or the inlet line is leaking
Elimination: Check the inlet line for air pockets and/or air leaks.
4) The packing or seal in the stuffing box is worn, causing air to leak into the pump housing
Elimination measures: Check packing or seal and replace as needed. Check whether the lubrication is normal.
5) Insufficient suction head when pumping hot or volatile liquids
Elimination measures: increase the suction head, consult the manufacturer.
6) The submersion depth of the bottom valve or inlet pipe is not enough
Elimination measures: Consult the manufacturer for the correct immersion depth, and use the baffle to eliminate eddy current.
7) The pump casing gasket is damaged
Elimination measures: Check the condition of the gasket and replace it as required.

 

{3}The power consumption of the pump is too large
1) The direction of rotation is wrong
Elimination measures: check the rotation direction.
2) Impeller damage
Elimination measures: Check the impeller and replace it as required.
3) The rotating parts are bitten
Elimination measures: Check whether the clearance of internal wear parts is normal.
4) Axis bending
Elimination measures: straighten the shaft or replace it as required.
5) Speed is too high
Elimination measures: Check the winding voltage of the motor or the steam pressure delivered to the turbine.
6) The water head is below the rated value. Too much fluid is pumped
Elimination measures: Consult the manufacturer. Install throttle and cut impeller.
7) The liquid is heavier than expected
Elimination measures: check specific gravity and viscosity.
8) Stuffing box is not correctly filled (insufficient stuffing, no correct stuffing or running close, stuffing is too tight)
Elimination measures: check the stuffing and reload the stuffing box.
9) Incorrect bearing lubrication or bearing wear
Elimination measures: check and replace as required.
10) The operating gap between wear rings is not correct
Elimination measures: Check whether the gap is correct. Replace wear rings on pump housing and/or impeller as required.
11) The stress of the pipe on the pump housing is too large
Removal measures: remove stress and consult the manufacturer's representative. Check alignment after stress relief.

 

{4}the pump stuffing box leakage is too large
1) Axis bending
Elimination measures: straighten the shaft or replace it as required.
2) The coupling or pump and drive device are not aligned
Elimination measures: Check the alignment, if necessary, re-alignment.
3) Bearing lubrication is not correct or bearing wear
Elimination measures: check and replace as required.

 

{5}the bearing temperature is too high
1) Axis bending
Elimination measures: straighten the shaft or replace it as required.
2) The coupling or pump and drive device are not aligned
Elimination measures: Check the alignment, if necessary, re-alignment.
3) Bearing lubrication is not correct or bearing wear
Elimination measures: check and replace as required.
4) The stress of the pipe on the pump housing is too large
Removal measures: Remove stress and consult the manufacturer representative. Check alignment after stress relief.
5) Too much lubricant
Elimination measures: Remove the plug, so that excessive grease automatically discharged. If it is an oil-lubricated pump, the oil is discharged to the correct oil level.

 

{6}pump stuffing box overheating
1) The packing or seal in the pump packing box is worn, causing air to leak into the pump housing
Elimination measures: Check packing or seal and replace as needed. Check whether the lubrication is normal.
2) The pump stuffing box does not have the correct packing (insufficient packing, no correct stuffing or running together, the packing is too tight)
Elimination measures: check the stuffing and reload the stuffing box.
3) The pump packing or mechanical seal has a design problem
Elimination measures: Consult the manufacturer.
4) The mechanical seal of the pump is damaged
Elimination measures: check and replace as required. Consult the manufacturer.
5) The shaft sleeve of the pump is scratched
Elimination measures: repair, remachining or replacement as required.
6) The pump packing is too tight or the mechanical seal is not properly adjusted
Elimination measures: check and adjust the packing, as required to replace. Adjust the mechanical seal (refer to the manufacturer's instructions provided with the pump or consult the manufacturer).

 

{7}The rotating parts are difficult to rotate or have friction
1) The pump shaft is bent
Elimination measures: straighten the shaft or replace it as required.
2) The operating gap between the wear rings of the pump is incorrect
Elimination measures: Check whether the gap is correct. Replace wear ring of pump housing or impeller as required.
3) The stress of the pipe on the pump shell is too large
Removal measures: remove stress and consult the manufacturer's representative. Check alignment after stress relief.
4) The pump shaft or impeller ring swing is too large
Elimination measures: Check rotating parts and bearings, and replace worn or damaged parts as required.
5) There is dirt between the pump impeller and the wear ring of the pump shell, and there is dirt in the wear ring of the pump shell
Elimination measures: clean and check the wear ring, and replace it as required. Block and eliminate sources of dirt.

You Might Also Like

Send Inquiry